USA Today
Review by Marc Saltzman. "A fantastic buy whether or not players are old enough to remember these games."

GameSpot
Review by Jeff Gerstmann, 63%. "If you're looking to play these 12 classic ... games again, your best bet is, of course, to hunt down the original arcade machines. However, if you don't have an empty garage or a pile of money to spare, Atari Anniversary Edition emulates the 12 games well enough."